As for Tuesday's show, I thought Jason Castro stole the night. He was great, and it was surprising consider the material. I actually loved Brooke's performance. It was raw and emotional and somehow had me hooked. I thought it was better than "Every Breath You take" Chris.

David Cook was good, but I just wasn't as impressed. His Billie Jean night is still tops for me. I liked the originality, but the performance was lacking.

Syesha and Carly were good, but clearly not as good as the guys!

David A is still the clear winner here, but I love how good all the contestants are this year compared to the past seasons.