American Idol Reviews
American Idol: Fall of Castro
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
There were no surprises tonight as the wacky dread head got the boot.
American Idol: I Was Thinkin Bob Marley!
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
The Final Four were supposed to bring the house down with a giant selection of rock and roll classics, but most were underwhelming instead.
American Idol: Fantastic Four
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
4
Neil Diamond sings, Simon reunites with his first love and another contestant hits the road.
American Idol: Rough Diamonds
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
Neil Diamond really likes the two Davids, and for good reason, since they outshined the rest of the Top 5.
American Idol: Five Alive
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
5
Simon was right when he called this a popularity contest. And apparently tonight’s evicted contestant just wasn’t popular enough.
American Idol: Grilled by Webber
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
11
The Top 6 take to Broadway for Andrew Lloyd Webber night.
American Idol: Too Many Cooks in the Kitchen
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
Another contestant sang their swan song tonight as the field narrowed to just six contestants.
American Idol: Carey Me Away
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
7
Mariah Carey introduces the Top 7 to her songbook, and surprisingly, it’s the guys who deliver the goods.
American Idol: Goodbye Mate!
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
11
Say hello to the first big shocker of the season.
American Idol: Idol Gives Back
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
A multitude of stars pack the “Idol” stage to raise money for charity.
American Idol: Dream On
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
6
The judges weren’t overly enthused on inspirational song night, as only two singers prove their worth.
American Idol: 9 to 8
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
6
Dolly sings, Ramiele cries and Simon apologizes to everyone as another contestant makes the sad journey home.
American Idol: Welcome to Dollywood
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
5
Dolly Parton stops by to coach the Top 9.
American Idol: And Then There Were Nine
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
5
This season’s happiest contestant gets sent home.
American Idol: Cook Country
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
10
For the fourth week in a row, it’s David Cook’s world and we’re just rockin’ in it.
American Idol: Idol’s Ten Most Wanted
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
No one said making it to the Top 10 was going to be easy. Just ask tonight’s bottom three.
American Idol: Marginal Mystery Tour
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
7
The Fab Eleven did their best Beatles impressions, but only a few could be called memorable.
American Idol: Idol’s Eleven
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
4
One person was eliminated, but it’s not the one you think.
American Idol: A Hard Day’s Night
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
The Lennon-McCartney songbook proves treacherous for many and shifts the competition in new directions.
American Idol: The New Top 12
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
5
In a relatively shocker-free ceremony, “Idol” chose its Top 12 Finalists.
American Idol: The Top 8 Girls
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
The Top 8 Girls set the “Idol” stage on fire as they belted their best performances yet.
American Idol: The Top 8 Guys
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
Once again, it was all about the Davids as the Top 8 Guys tried to croon their way into the finals.
American Idol: Another Four Bite the Dust
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
In a shocker of an elimination, four more contestants said sayonara to the “Idol” stage.
American Idol: The Top 10 Girls
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
The Top 10 Girls fell victim to bad song choices and cleared the road for only one super singer.
American Idol: The Top 10 Guys
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
The Top 10 Guys tried to grab America’s votes, but only two were a hit with the judges.
American Idol: Four Out the Door
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
Four kids got the boot tonight as we whittled down to twenty hopefuls.
American Idol: The Top 12 Girls
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
6
The Top 12 Girls fought for a place in the finals tonight, with impressive vocals from some and shaky performances from others.
American Idol: The Top 12 Guys
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
The Top 12 Guys took the stage, sang some ‘60s songs and battled for America’s votes.
American Idol: Atlanta Auditions
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
The episode wasn't so juicy, but there were a few peaches in Georgia.
American Idol: Omaha Auditions
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
The judges pick through the crops -- and the crap -- to find the cream of America's heartland.
American Idol: Charleston Auditions
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
It may be the Holy City, but it certainly wasn't the most talented.
American Idol: San Diego Auditions
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
We're still in the audition stage, but at least the shows are only an hour now!
American Idol: Dallas Auditions
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
Sure everything is bigger in Texas, but was it also lamer?
American Idol: Philadelphia Auditions
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
The new season kicks off... did Philly have some brotherly love to spare for this 2-hour extravaganza?
American Idol: That's All Folks!
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
6
Absolutely no surprises here. Go home -- it's over kids!
American Idol: The Final 2
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
It was Blake and Jordin's last chance to wow us. The songwriting winner also got showcased -- and could have cost someone the "AI" crown.
American Idol: Oh Snap!
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
5
Better late than never, we finally got this season’s shocking elimination.
American Idol: The Final 3
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
Three songs separate each of the contestants from a spot in the finals.
American Idol: LaKisha Gets Kicked to the Curb
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
LaKisha may be "Stayin' Alive," but she ain't staying on the show.
American Idol: Dead as Disco
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
Each of the contestants brought the house down (and in some cases, to a screeching halt) with songs and help from Barry Gibb.
American Idol: Phil & Chris Get a Taste of "Bad Medicine"
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
The show is a little lighter tonight, after two of the contestants get sent home.
American Idol: Bon Jovi Night
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
4
The final six contestants spend an entire hour paying homage to the musical stylings of Jon Bon Jovi.
American Idol: Idol Gives Back -- Again
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
The grand finale for tonight's two-hour fundraising extravaganza decided not to kick anyone when we were down.
American Idol: Idols Give Back
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
A lot of tears and a whole lot of cheese was plentiful in tonight's ode to inspirational songs.
American Idol: Country Roads Take Sanjaya Home
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
9
Vote for the Worst and many other sites couldn't ensure that America's more animated William Hung would take home the "Idol" crown.
American Idol: Haley's Coming Home
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
3
The scantily clad cutie couldn't turn the beat -- or the voting -- around, and got sent packing.
American Idol: Latin Heat
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
With the help of Jennifer Lopez, the top 8 contestants tried to inject a little spice into their song choices.
American Idol: No "Smile" for Gina Glocksen
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
Apparently the rocker chick couldn't live up to AI's standards night.
American Idol: American Standards
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
Tony Bennett mentors this week, but that don't mean a thing if the 9 finalists can't swing.
American Idol: Bye-Bye Curly
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
After a lackluster interpretation of the Police, Chris Sligh has been sent home.
American Idol: Pop Goes the Idol
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
Hey baby! Pop-punk princess Gwen Stefani helps the kids with their performances. Too bad she couldn't save Sanjaya from a bad hair day.
American Idol: Who's Crying Now?
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
4
Another shocking elimination shows that there's something awry with America's biggest TV show.
American Idol: Idols Invade the British Classics
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
9
The top 11 croon top tunes from the swinging '60s -- and what a long, strange trip it was.
American Idol: 6 Men Enter, One Man Leaves
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
After weeks of wowing the judges, a case of forgotten lyrics sends one "Idol" hopeful home.
American Idol: The Top 12 Sing
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
5
Diana Ross gets crazy in a different way -- helping the kids get down and learn some songs from her classic Motown years.
American Idol: The Final 12
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
9
Tears were shed, shocking moments were had, and the final 12 contestants were announced.
American Idol: Last Ladies' Night
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
Tonight was the last of the catfights before the final 12 are selected -- and some of these kitties had their claws out.
American Idol: The Not-So-Great 8
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
The guys' side of the "American Idol" talent pool is getting smaller -- and in some spots, a bit tired.
American Idol: 4 More Get the Axe
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
4
Two surprises in tonight's elimination round -- and both of those surprises were attached to previous contestant Kellie Pickler.
American Idol: Top 10 Girls
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
The last night of dedications allowed the ladies to showcase that special someone, as well as some vocal talents.
American Idol: Top 10 Men
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
It was dedication night and the top 10 guys were sending their love out in song form.
American Idol: First 4 Shown the Door
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
There were no surprises in the first results show, as two men and two women were sent home.
American Idol: Top 12 Girls
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
1
It's a crooner catfight, as the top 12 girls try to secure the top 10 singing spots.
American Idol: Top 12 Boy Toys
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
2
The guys take the stage first, in an attempt to sing their way into one of the top 10 slots.
American Idol: The 24 Chosen Ones
Posted to: American Idol Reviews
| Comments:
0
If you blinked, you probably missed Hollywood week. The final 24 have been chosen!